同辈竞争影响基金经理冒险行为的机制研究
DOI:
作者:
作者单位:

作者简介:

通讯作者:

基金项目:


The Mechanism of Peer Competition Influencing Fund Managers’ Risk-taking Behavior
Author:
Affiliation:

Fund Project:

  • 摘要
  • |
  • 图/表
  • |
  • 访问统计
  • |
  • 参考文献
  • |
  • 相似文献
  • |
  • 引证文献
  • |
  • 资源附件
    摘要:

    随着基金业的蓬勃发展,基金已成为我国资本市场的重要组成部分。基金市场竞争的日益激烈使基金经理的冒险行为备受关注,现有文献主要基于“业绩—资金流—报酬—冒险”的分析范式,从基金业绩排名角度研究竞争对基金经理冒险行为的影响,但鲜有文献研究市场竞争强度对基金经理冒险行为的影响,更缺乏相关经验证据。本文认为,同辈基金(具有相似风格的基金)之间的竞争对基金经理冒险行为具有显著影响:在基金投资收益不确定和同辈基金存在替代效应的情形下,同辈竞争的加剧会增强投资者基金风格偏好对基金业绩偏好的掩盖,导致投资者业绩追逐降低,减弱“业绩—资金流—报酬”机制的激励效应,进而对基金经理的冒险动机和行为产生抑制作用;在冒险行为结果不确定和竞争具有收益递减效应的情形下,同辈竞争加剧会导致基金业绩下降,使冒险行为的预期收益降低,同时也使基金经理被解职的风险增加,进而抑制基金经理的冒险动机和行为。采用2005—2020年中国开放式基金数据的分析发现:同辈基金数量与基金的风险调整比率、重仓股集中度和市场偏离度均显著负相关,表明同辈竞争的加剧会使基金投资组合的风险水平下降;基金业绩与下期同辈基金平均资金流显著负相关,表明同辈基金的替代效应明显;同辈基金数量增加会弱化基金较同辈超额收益对基金资金流的正向影响,表明同辈竞争的加剧会降低投资者业绩追逐;基金业绩对同辈竞争影响基金经理冒险行为的部分中介效应明显,表明同辈竞争的加剧可以通过降低基金业绩来抑制基金经理冒险行为。相比已有文献,本文主要从三个方面进行了拓展和深化:一是从理论上探讨基金市场竞争强度增加对基金经理冒险行为的抑制作用;二是通过三维风格空间网络对同辈基金进行识别,构建一种基于风格相似性刻画基金市场竞争强度的方法;三是采用中国开放式基金的数据进行实证检验,为同辈竞争的基金经理冒险行为抑制效应提供经验证据。本文揭示了同辈竞争加剧对基金经理冒险行的抑制效应及其影响机制,为进一步优化基金市场结构和规范基金市场管理提供了经验借鉴和政策启示。应加强对基金申报的宏观调控和基金运行监管,使基金市场竞争维持在适度的范围内,有效发挥同辈竞争对基金经理行为的改善效应,进而促进基金业健康发展和人民财富增长。

    Abstract:

    With the vigorous development of fund industry, fund has become an important part of China’s capital market. The increasingly fierce competition in the fund market makes the risk behavior of fund managers attract much attention. Existing literature mainly studies the influence of competition on fund managers’ risk-taking behavior from the perspective of fund performance ranking based on the analytical paradigm of “performance-capital flow-return-risk-taking”. However, few literatures study the influence of market competition intensity on fund managers’ risk-taking behavior, let alone relevant empirical evidence. This paper argues that competition among peer funds (funds with similar styles) has a significant impact on fund managers’ risk-taking behavior. Under the circumstance of uncertain fund investment returns and the substitution effect of peer funds, the intensification of peer competition will enhance the cover-up of investors’ fund style preference on fund performance preference, leading to lower investors’ pursuit of performance, weakening the incentive effect of the “performance-capital flow-return” mechanism, and inhibiting fund managers’ risk-taking motives and behaviors. In a situation where the outcome of risk-taking behavior is uncertain and competition has diminishing returns, increased peer competition will lead to a decline in fund performance, reduce the expected return of risk-taking behavior, and increase the risk of fund managers being dismissed, thereby inhibiting fund managers’ risk-taking motivation and behavior. Based on the data of China open-end funds from 2005 to 2020, it is found that the number of peer funds is significantly negatively correlated with the risk adjustment ratio, the concentration degree of heavy holdings and the degree of market deviation, which indicates that the intensification of peer competition will reduce the risk level of fund portfolio. The fund performance is negatively correlated with the average fund flow of the peer fund in the next period, indicating that the substitution effect of the peer fund is obvious. The increase in the number of peer funds will weaken the positive effect of fund’s excess returns on fund flows, indicating that the intensification of peer competition will reduce investors’ pursuit of performance. The partial mediating effect of fund performance on peer competition on fund managers’ risk-taking behavior is obvious, indicating that the intensification of peer competition can inhibit fund managers’ risk-taking behavior by reducing fund performance. Compared with the existing literature, this paper mainly expands and deepens this study from three aspects: the first is to theoretically discuss the inhibition effect of increasing fund market competition intensity on fund managers’ risk-taking behaviors; the second is to identify the peer fund through the three-dimensional style space network and construct a method to describe the competitive intensity of fund market based on style similarity; the third is to provide empirical evidence for the inhibition effect of fund managers’ risk-taking behaviors by using the data of China’s open-end funds. This paper explains the inhibitory effect of intensified peer competition on fund managers’ risk-taking behaviors and its influencing mechanism, and provides experience and policy inspiration for further optimizing the structure of the fund market and standardizing the management of the fund market. It is necessary to strengthen the macro-control and supervision of fund declaration and fund operation, so as to maintain the fund market competition within a moderate range, and effectively exert the improvement effect of peer competition on fund managers’ behavior, thereby promoting the healthy development of the fund industry and the growth of people’s wealth.

    参考文献
    相似文献
    引证文献
引用本文

王文南翔,胡日东,张宬.同辈竞争影响基金经理冒险行为的机制研究[J].西部论坛,2022,32(2):110-124

复制
分享
文章指标
  • 点击次数:
  • 下载次数:
历史
  • 收稿日期:
  • 最后修改日期:
  • 录用日期:
  • 在线发布日期: 2022-06-12